REVIEW: A BEAUTIFUL NOISE - Shines like a Diamond

The risk with any musical built on a hit catalogue is that the songs do all the work and the story just stands there. A Beautiful Noise sidesteps that trap by giving the songs a job, and by giving Neil Diamond a therapist.

The show opens with the older Neil in a consulting room. He is there because, according to his family,  he has become "difficult". But in therapy he has a problem: words don’t come easily, and it is his songs that speak for him. That is the engine of this performance. As the therapist guides him back through his life, we jump between decades while the older man watches his younger self live it all again.

It is a smart structure. It lets the musical be more than a parade of greatest-hits. Songs arrive when the story needs them, and some arrive in fresh interpretations that make familiar material feel newly lit. Broadway's Will Swenson brings down the house playing the young Neil, with Aussie Terence Crawford deep in reflection as the the older. Monica Sayers plays the Doctor.

What is surprising is how much sadness hangs over the story. Neil’s eternal blues are given real room, along with his battle against loneliness and the “clouds” that follow him. The show covers his history without flinching, including a record deal with a label run by mobsters, two divorces and his psychoanalysis. The rough edges of stardom are all here, and the show is better for not smoothing them.

But Act Two is where the production finds its rhythm. It opens with real energy, then alternates between full-scale concert numbers, staged as though the audience is at an actual Neil Diamond concert, and quiet, intimate exchanges between Neil and his therapist. That balance is handled well, and the pacing never sags. In one of those quieter scenes he admits he has never not felt alone. The line is delivered softly, but with the impact of a hammer, and it explains a lot as his lyrics over the decades are dissected within the therapy.

The craft also deserves a mention. The creative team has serious pedigree. Director Michael Mayer won a Tony Award for Spring Awakening and also directed Hedwig and the Angry Inch. Choreographer Steven Hoggett, an Olivier winner, brings the movement. The script is by Anthony McCarten, a four-time Oscar nominee for Bohemian Rhapsody and The Two Popes. The design team includes David Rockwell (scenic), Kevin Adams (lighting) and Jessica Paz (sound), while Sonny Paladino supervises the music, with orchestrations shared with Brian Usifer and Bob Gaudio. The result is polished and confident staging, a superb ensemble and a live band that is a pleasure. Given the catalogue, that matters a great deal.

The finale is the show’s finest. As the story resolves, the older Neil finally sings, joined by his younger self. It is a monumental moment. Be prepared for tears in the audience.

This is a heartfelt, entertaining musical that understands what the songs have meant to people and why. That meaning runs deep in Australia. Diamond toured here seven times with promoter Paul Dainty, from the 1976 Thank You Australia tour through to 2015. His 1972 live album Hot August Night spent 29 weeks at number one and 65 weeks in the charts, the third-longest-charting album of its era in Australian music history. 

The musical is made in collaboration with Diamond himself, and from the Australian producers of TINA – The Tina Turner Musical. It honours that history, and even the casual fan will find something to love. There's every reason to experience this production.

A Beautiful Noise: The Neil Diamond Musical plays at Sydney Lyric, Pyrmont, with the season now extending to 10 January 2027. 

Bookings at theneildiamondmusical.com.au

(Images: Jeff Busby; supplied)

Comments