REVIEW: DIXON AND DAUGHTERS — The Old Fitz Paints a Portrait of Women Who Survive


 "I kept thinking about the lives they'd lived," writes director Kim Hardwick in her program note, "and the love they have for one another, even when they struggle to show it." It is a generous way into a play that deals with some very dark material, and it is exactly the right way. Dixon and Daughters, British playwright Deborah Bruce's unflinching domestic drama, is not a play about women who have failed each other. It is a play about women who have survived, at considerable cost, and are still trying to work out what that means.

Significantly, the play was originally developed with Clean Break, a UK theatre company founded by women in prison and theatre practitioners, dedicated to telling stories that challenge perceptions of women and the criminal justice system. That lineage matters. It gives the work an authority that lifts it well above the territory of domestic melodrama.

In this Australian premiere, presented by Tiny Dog Productions at the Old Fitzroy Theatre in Woolloomooloo, we meet Mary Dixon as she returns home after three months in prison. She notices immediately that things have been moved. Furniture. Household arrangements. Small domestic shifts that are not small at all. They are evidence of a household that continued without her, and is not entirely certain it wants to revert. The pedantry with which Vanessa Downing's Mary catalogues these changes tells us everything we need to know about a woman reasserting control over the only domain available to her. It is a beautifully observed opening. Confronting, precise, unrestrained, and fully loaded.

Downing brings considerable authority to Mary, a performance that resists easy sympathy without ever losing our attention. Her credits span Sydney Theatre Company, Ensemble Theatre, Bell Shakespeare and Griffin, and every year of that experience is evident in the gravity she brings to a role that could easily have tipped into caricature. She does not let it.

The daughters, being Julie (Romney Hamilton), Briana (Sarah Jane Starr), grand daughter Ella (Danette Potgieter) and ex-prison-mate Leigh (Rylea Eilis), each carry their own version of the family's unresolved weight, and each is distinctly convincingly drawn. Hamilton brings a tightly coiled energy to Julie; Starr, a NIDA graduate and classically trained dancer, brings physical precision alongside emotional range; Potgieter and Eilis acquit themselves with confidence in what for both are significant showcase roles. 

Linda Nicholls-Gidley as Bernie, the eldest daughter, completes the ensemble of six, pulling double duty as the production's dialect coach, a credit that speaks for itself in a cast where not a single accent slips.

That consistency of accent is no small achievement. Dixon and Daughters is rooted in a specific working-class English world, and a misplaced vowel would puncture the illusion immediately. None do. The dialect work, under Nicholls-Gidley's guidance, is seamless throughout.

Hardwick keeps the production clean and purposeful. Mia MacCormick's set is very impressive and Amelie Brown's costumes establish the world with economy. Topaz Marlay-Cole's lighting and Nicky Pardesi's sound design support without intruding.

Bruce's script does not rush toward revelation. Humour is deployed with precision, arriving at moments that briefly lower the audience's guard before the next wave arrives. The content warnings attached to this production are not decorative. But the play treats its darkest material without melodrama and without false resolution. Healing is possible here, but it is incomplete and costly, as real things tend to be.

In every matter of performance and production this is polished, purposeful work. Tiny Dog Productions have done this play, and Sydney audiences, a genuine service.

Dixon and Daughters. The Old Fitzroy Theatre, 129 Dowling Street, Woolloomooloo. Season continues to 3 October 2026.

Tickets and more info: https://purchase.oldfitztheatre.com.au/EventAvailability?EventId=1201

(Images: Campbell Parsons)

Comments